| 2000 | May 23 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue | 16 - 0 | Welland Wizards White |
| 2002 | May 23 | Grimsby Griffins | 2 - 5 | Lincoln Storm |
| 2003 | May 26 | Welland Wizards Red | 3 - 4 | Niagara Falls Titans White |
| 2004 | May 28 | Grimsby Griffins | 5 - 3 | Welland Wizards Red |
| 2007 | May 28 | NOTL Rangers | 1 - 10 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red |
| 2005 | May 28 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White | 2 - 1 | Lincoln Storm |
| 2006 | May 28 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue | 3 - 0 | Niagara Falls Titans White |
| 2010 | May 30 | Lincoln Storm | 3 - 3 | Niagara Falls Titans White |
| 2008 | May 30 | Welland Wizards White | 1 - 7 | Grimsby Griffins |
| 2009 | May 30 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White | 1 - 2 | Welland Wizards Red |
| 2011 | May 30 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue | 4 - 0 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red |
| 2014 | Jun 6 | NOTL Rangers | 8 - 0 | Welland Wizards White |
| 2015 | Jun 6 | Welland Wizards Red | 1 - 5 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue |
| 2012 | Jun 6 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red | 4 - 1 | Grimsby Griffins |
| 2013 | Jun 6 | Niagara Falls Titans White | 3 - 0 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White |
| 2016 | Jun 13 | Grimsby Griffins | 1 - 5 | Niagara Falls Titans White |
| 2019 | Jun 13 | NOTL Rangers | 0 - 8 | Lincoln Storm |
| 2017 | Jun 13 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red | 10 - 1 | Welland Wizards White |
| 2018 | Jun 13 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue | 9 - 0 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White |
| 2021 | Jun 20 | Lincoln Storm | 1 - 10 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue |
| 2023 | Jun 20 | Welland Wizards White | 0 - 6 | Welland Wizards Red |
| 2022 | Jun 20 | Niagara Falls Titans White | 10 - 0 | NOTL Rangers |
| 2020 | Jun 20 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White | 2 - 3 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red |
| 2025 | Jun 27 | Grimsby Griffins | 8 - 1 | NOTL Rangers |
| 2024 | Jun 27 | Welland Wizards Red | 1 - 1 | Lincoln Storm |
| 2026 | Jun 27 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White | 11 - 1 | Welland Wizards White |
| 2027 | Jun 27 | Niagara Falls Titans White | 1 - 2 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red |
| 2030 | Jul 4 | Grimsby Griffins | 2 - 4 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White |
| 2031 | Jul 4 | Welland Wizards White | 0 - 6 | Lincoln Storm |
| 2028 | Jul 4 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red | 7 - 0 | Welland Wizards Red |
| 2029 | Jul 4 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue | 8 - 0 | NOTL Rangers |
| 2033 | Jul 11 | Lincoln Storm | 3 - 1 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White |
| 2034 | Jul 11 | Niagara Falls Titans White | 0 - 4 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue |
| 2032 | Jul 11 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red | 6 - 0 | NOTL Rangers |
| 2035 | Jul 18 | Lincoln Storm | 1 - 3 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red |
| 2036 | Jul 18 | NOTL Rangers | 0 - 6 | Welland Wizards Red |
| 2038 | Jul 18 | Welland Wizards White | 1 - 8 | Niagara Falls Titans White |
| 2037 | Jul 18 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue | 7 - 1 | Grimsby Griffins |
| 2041 | Jul 25 | Lincoln Storm | 5 - 0 | Grimsby Griffins |
| 2039 | Jul 25 | Welland Wizards White | 0 - 13 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue |
| 2042 | Jul 25 | Niagara Falls Titans White | 5 - 3 | Welland Wizards Red |
| 2040 | Jul 25 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White | 5 - 3 | NOTL Rangers |
| 2046 | Aug 1 | Grimsby Griffins | 8 - 0 | Welland Wizards White |
| 2045 | Aug 1 | Welland Wizards Red | 5 - 1 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White |
| 2044 | Aug 1 | Niagara Falls Titans White | 5 - 2 | Lincoln Storm |
| 2043 | Aug 1 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red | 0 - 5 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue |
| 2047 | Aug 8 | Grimsby Griffins | 1 - 10 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red |
| 2048 | Aug 8 | Welland Wizards White | 0 - 3 | NOTL Rangers |
| 2049 | Aug 8 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White | 1 - 7 | Niagara Falls Titans White |
| 2050 | Aug 8 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue | 4 - 0 | Welland Wizards Red |
| 2001 | Aug 13 | NOTL Rangers | 1 - 7 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White |
| 2053 | Aug 15 | Lincoln Storm | 9 - 1 | NOTL Rangers |
| 2054 | Aug 15 | Welland Wizards White | 1 - 2 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red |
| 2052 | Aug 15 | Niagara Falls Titans White | 4 - 3 | Grimsby Griffins |
| 2051 | Aug 15 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White | 1 - 10 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue |
| 3173 | Aug 20 | Welland Wizards Red | 3 - 0 | Grimsby Griffins |
| 2058 | Aug 22 | NOTL Rangers | 0 - 13 | Niagara Falls Titans White |
| 2056 | Aug 22 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red | 10 - 1 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White |
| 2055 | Aug 22 | Welland Wizards Red | 8 - 0 | Welland Wizards White |
| 2057 | Aug 22 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue | 10 - 0 | Lincoln Storm |
| 2062 | Aug 27 | Niagara Falls Titans White | 6 - 0 | Welland Wizards White |
| 2061 | Aug 27 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red | 2 - 2 | Lincoln Storm |
| 2059 | Aug 27 | Grimsby Griffins | 0 - 9 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue |
| 2060 | Aug 27 | Welland Wizards Red | 9 - 0 | NOTL Rangers |
| 2065 | Aug 29 | Lincoln Storm | 0 - 7 | Welland Wizards Red |
| 2066 | Aug 29 | NOTL Rangers | 2 - 9 | Grimsby Griffins |
| 2064 | Aug 29 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red | 1 - 3 | Niagara Falls Titans White |
| 2063 | Aug 29 | Welland Wizards White | 3 - 2 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White |
| 2068 | Sep 5 | Lincoln Storm | 6 - 0 | Welland Wizards White |
| 2069 | Sep 5 | NOTL Rangers | 0 - 12 | Niagara Falls Titans Blue |
| 2067 | Sep 5 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves White | 10 - 1 | Grimsby Griffins |
| 2070 | Sep 5 | Welland Wizards Red | 2 - 0 | St Catharines Club Roma Wolves Red |
